President Joe Biden's decision to include cluster bombs in the latest $800 million weapons package for Ukraine has sparked controversy and drawn criticism from both Democrats and international allies. Cluster bombs, which are banned by more than 120 countries under the Geneva Convention, have the potential to cause significant harm to civilians. Critics argue that providing these weapons to Ukraine could result in the loss of innocent lives and undermine the moral leadership of the United States. Rep. Barbara Lee stated that using cluster bombs crosses a line and called for a reconsideration of the decision.

On the other hand, the Biden administration has defended its decision, stating that the cluster munitions are necessary to support Ukraine in its defense against Russian aggression. President Biden acknowledged that it was a difficult decision but argued that Ukraine needs the weapons to counter Russian forces effectively. The administration believes that the harm caused by Russia's use of cluster munitions and other weapons outweighs the potential harm caused by the use of cluster munitions by Ukraine.

International allies including the UK, Canada, and Spain have expressed their opposition to the use of cluster bombs and have pointed to the Convention on Cluster Munitions, which prohibits their use. Amnesty International has also raised concerns about the threat cluster munitions pose to civilian lives, even after a conflict has ended.

The use of cluster munitions has long-term implications, as unexploded bomblets can continue to harm civilians for years. The impact on innocent lives is well-documented, with examples from Ukraine, Laos, Vietnam, and Yemen. Critics argue that the United States should align with the international consensus against the use of cluster munitions and prioritize protecting civilians.

The question remains: Is President Biden's decision to provide cluster bombs to Ukraine justified? The answer may depend on one's perspective on the potential risks and the broader context of the conflict.